A controversial proposal in Hawaii that would have allowed the state to override local zoning rules, permitting denser building in residential neighborhoods, has been shelved for the second consecutive year. The bill, sponsored by Sen. Stanley Chang, would have enabled subdividing lots to as small as 2,500 square feet and allowed up to three homes on each lot.
Chang withdrew the bill before a Senate vote, citing widespread community opposition as the reason for the decision. Rep. Luke Evslin’s similar House bill also failed to gain traction. Chang has expressed his intention to support Evslin should he reintroduce the measure in 2027.
Honolulu City Council Chairman Tommy Waters criticized the proposal, warning it could lead to reckless overdevelopment. Waters spearheaded a campaign against the bill, emphasizing the importance of county authority over zoning due to their local insights. He articulated concerns that increased density could make properties more attractive to out-of-state buyers, potentially pricing local families out of the market.
Chang and Evslin argued the bill could alleviate Hawaii’s housing crisis by increasing the supply of homes. However, the absence of an affordability mandate raised concerns among opponents who fear it would only benefit developers.
The Honolulu Department of Permitting cautioned about potential impacts on infrastructure, noting particular concerns for neighborhoods with larger lots. The department also highlighted parking challenges due to reduced requirements in the bill.
Groups like the Maui Chamber of Commerce, AARP Hawaii, and Grassroot Institute of Hawaii supported the bill for its potential to increase housing availability, while opponents cited safety and infrastructure issues inherent in older neighborhoods with narrow streets.
