Luigi Mangione to pursue psychiatric defense at trial

·

·

1–2 minutes

Summary

Luigi Mangione’s lawyers said they will argue he was in “extreme emotional disturbance” during the 2024 killing of Brian Thompson.

Why this matters

The defense could affect whether jurors consider manslaughter rather than murder, with major consequences for sentencing. The case also continues in both state and federal court, where Mangione faces possible life sentences.

Luigi Mangione, accused of fatally shooting UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in New York City, will argue a psychiatric defense at trial.

Judge Gregory Carro said Wednesday that Mangione’s lawyers told the court they would argue he was in a state of “extreme emotional disturbance” when he allegedly carried out the December 2024 shooting.

Under New York law, defendants in murder cases can argue they were not fully responsible for their actions because they were in a state of extreme emotional disturbance at the time of a killing.

An emotional-disturbance defense would amount to an acknowledgment that Mangione carried out the shooting, but under impaired judgment. It is different from an insanity plea, which could result in a sentence being served in a psychiatric facility rather than prison.

Thompson was killed outside a hotel in Midtown Manhattan. Police said the words “delay”, “deny”, and “depose” were written on the suspect’s ammunition, which they described as a reference to how health insurers avoid paying claims.

Mangione, 28, previously pleaded not guilty to state and federal charges connected to the killing. He sat between two lawyers in a blue suit during Wednesday’s hearing.

His state trial is scheduled to begin Sept. 8. His federal trial, which includes stalking charges, is set to begin Oct. 13.

He could face life in prison if convicted in either case.

In January, U.S. District Judge Margaret Garnett dismissed murder and weapons charges in the federal case on technical grounds, removing the possibility that Mangione could face the death penalty.

  • U.S. to phase out HIV funding for South Africa

    A U.S. State Department official said a “phased drawdown” would begin because of “South Africa’s failure to make demonstrable progress on policy requests by the administration.”

    Full story +

  • Italy cancels U.S. visit after Trump comments on Meloni

    Trump has accused Meloni of failing to help the U.S. with NATO and threatened to pull U.S. troops from Italy, saying Rome “has not been of any help to us” in the Iran war.

    Full story +

  • U.S. probes German drug pricing, tariff risk rises

    Earlier this month, the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative proposed tariffs of up to 12.5% on dozens of economies in a separate investigation into forced labor concerns.

    Full story +

  • U.S. strike on suspected smugglers kills 3 at sea

    The deaths bring the total number of people killed in U.S. strikes since early September to at least 211.

    Full story +

  • Stocks Slip as Iran Nuclear Talks Face Delay

    Bitcoin fell for a fourth straight day. Gold was headed for a third weekly loss, trading around $4,150 an ounce.

    Full story +

  • Pentagon seeking $80 billion for Iran war, other costs

    A Pentagon official said in April that the Iran war had cost about $25 billion, but the full cost of the war has remained unclear.

    Full story +

  • Meta sought child-safety lawsuit shield in KOSA

    The effort came as Meta faced youth-safety litigation, including thousands of claims consolidated in California state court and separate lawsuits by states and school districts.

    Full story +

  • 3 hikers die amid extreme heat in Grand Canyon

    Despite a rapid response and aerial support, all three hikers were dead by the time first responders reached them, the park service said.

    Full story +

  • High Court to weigh veterans’ route around VA review

    The case asks whether district courts can hear constitutional challenges to veterans benefits statutes.

    Full story +

  • German soccer fan invited to White House after viral posts

    The fan’s visits to American icons have drawn millions of views.

    Full story +