Appeals court lets Pentagon enforce escort rule

Summary

A federal appeals court let the Pentagon require escorted access for reporters while its appeal of a press policy ruling moves forward.

Why this matters

The ruling affects how journalists can report from the Pentagon while the broader lawsuit continues. It also could shape the balance between government security policies and press access at the Defense Department.

A federal appeals court ruled Monday that the Defense Department may require journalists to be escorted on Pentagon grounds while the Trump administration appeals a judge’s decision blocking enforcement of a new press access policy.

The 2-1 ruling by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit was not a final decision in The New York Times’ lawsuit against the Pentagon. But the majority said the administration was likely to succeed in showing that the escort requirement was legally valid.

The panel granted the government’s request to pause an April 9 decision by U.S. District Judge Paul Friedman, who had ruled that the Defense Department was violating an earlier order to restore access to the Pentagon for reporters.

Last fall, the Pentagon required reporters covering the military to accept a series of restrictions to keep daily access to the building. Many news organizations, including CBS News, ABC News, NBC News, CNN, and Fox News, declined to accept the new rules.

The Times sued, and Friedman last month struck down parts of the policy. He said several restrictions were unconstitutional, including one that suggested reporters who “solicit” sensitive information from military personnel could be considered a security risk and removed from the building.

Earlier this month, Friedman ruled that the Pentagon violated his order by issuing a revised policy that barred reporters from the building unless they were accompanied by government escorts.

In Monday’s ruling, Circuit Judges Justin Walker and Bradley Garcia, who were appointed by Trump and former President Joe Biden, respectively, wrote that “an agency may respond to an adverse ruling by adopting a revised policy.”

Circuit Judge J. Michelle Childs, who was appointed by Biden, dissented.

Defense Department spokesperson Sean Parnell welcomed the decision and said the department would continue arguing its case before the panel. In a statement posted on social media, Parnell said unescorted access to the Pentagon had led to the “regular unauthorized disclosure of sensitive and classified national defense information.”

“Since implementing the current access policy, the Department has seen a meaningful reduction in these unauthorized disclosures, which when they occur can endanger the lives of service members, intelligence personnel, and our allies,” he wrote.

  • ,

    Amazon adds AI audio Q&A to product pages

    The feature expands Amazon’s AI shopping tools, which also include Rufus, a generative artificial intelligence assistant for product research and comparisons, Interests, which tracks items based on shopper preferences, and “Help me decide,” which recommends products using a person’s searches, browsing, and shopping history.

    Full story +

  • ,

    Robinhood shares fall after Q1 misses estimates

    Net revenue increased 15% from the first quarter of last year to $1.07 billion.

    Full story +

  • Indonesia tries 4 soldiers in acid attack case

    The attack took place March 12 in Jakarta, when Yunus, a deputy coordinator at the Commission for Missing Persons and Victims of Violence, or KontraS, was riding a motorbike. Two men on another motorbike threw acid at him.

    Full story +

  • Mali ruler appears after attacks, vows response

    Islamic State in the Sahel Province and JNIM have fought each other for years. Since 2019, the two groups have clashed hundreds of times, killing more than 2,100 people.

    Full story +

  • South Korea court gives Yoon 7 years in prison

    The sentence added to the life term Yoon had already received on rebellion charges related to the same period. Yoon has appealed that sentence.

    Full story +

  • Chinese research vessel leaves waters near Japan

    The vessel was seen extending wire-like objects from its sides and stern until April 17, but remained in the area for about another week and a half.

    Full story +

  • Supreme Court to hear TPS cases on Haiti, Syria

    Advocates said ending TPS for Haiti and Syria could affect about 350,000 people and potentially shape future decisions involving roughly 1.3 million TPS holders from 17 countries, including Afghanistan, El Salvador, Ethiopia, Honduras, Nepal, Somalia, Sudan, Ukraine, Venezuela, and Yemen.

    Full story +

  • ,

    Coca-Cola profit rises, CEO flags consumer strain

    Coca-Cola reported net income of $3.92 billion, or $0.91 per share, up from $3.33 billion, or $0.77 per share, a year earlier. Net revenue was $12.47 billion, above the $12.24 billion estimate.

    Full story +

  • Senate blocks measure limiting Trump action on Cuba

    Republicans said the vote was unnecessary because there are no active U.S. hostilities against Cuba.

    Full story +

  • Report: Paragon silent in Italy spyware probe

    WhatsApp said Israeli American surveillance company Paragon provided the technology used in a hacking campaign that targeted about 90 people worldwide with its Graphite spyware.

    Full story +